![Director Provides Reminders For Obviousness Analy](/-/media/images/publications/2024/08/director-provides-reminders-for-obviousness-analysis/articleimage/director-provides-reminders-for-obviousness-analy.jpeg?rev=9bdae4dc72f54baab743c14d49f24c61&la=en&h=675&w=1080&hash=3514DF41162E6D1094EE0876AA431CAA)
Director Provides Reminders For Obviousness Analysis, PTAB Litigation Blog
Visit the PTAB Litigation Blog
On July 9, 2024, Director Vidal reversed and remanded a denial of institution of inter partes review (IPR) relating to three Spin Master patents. See Prime Time Toys LLC v. Spin Master, Inc., IPR Nos. 2023-01339, 2023-01348, 2023-01461, Paper 12 (PTAB July 9, 2024). Director Vidal found that the PTAB erred in its motivation-to-combine analysis and effectively required an expectation of “absolute success” for prior art combinations. Paper 12 at 7, 9.
* Scott Findley, a summer associate in the Minneapolis office assisted in the preparation of this blog.